採点基準のCoherence and Cohesionでは、段落と段落の関係が読み手に見えるかどうかが問われます。However はその関係を示す標識として働く語です。標識が道路の分岐点だけに立っていれば道順は分かりますが、100メートルおきに同じ標識が立っていれば、どこで曲がればよいのか分からなくなります。段落の内側で細かい対比のたびに使ってしまうと、これと同じことが起こります。
例に使うタスク
タスク例
Some people believe that public libraries are no longer necessary because information is available online. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
It is true that most factual information is now available online. Students can search academic databases from home, and search engines return results in seconds. However, not all of these sources are written by experts, and inaccurate claims spread quickly. Library staff are trained to check where information comes from, and they can guide users towards material that has been reviewed. However, it is still much faster to find information online than to visit a library in person.ボディ1の中だけで However を2回使っている。次の段落で立場を切り替えるときには3回目になる
It is true that most factual information is now available online. Students can search academic databases from home, and search engines return results in seconds. For someone who simply needs a date or a figure, a trip to a library is no longer necessary.ボディ1は認める内容だけで最後まで通している
○
However, libraries offer something that a search engine cannot. They provide a quiet public space that anyone can enter free of charge, and this matters most to people who have no suitable place to study at home.However はボディ2の1文目に1回だけ。ここが立場の切り替え地点だと一目で分かる
Online sources are convenient. However, some of them are not reliable.段落の途中で標識を使ってしまっている
○
Online sources are convenient, although some of them are not reliable.1文の中で処理しているので、段落の切れ目の However は温存できる
ここで注意したいのは、Nevertheless、Nonetheless、On the other hand も段落と段落の関係を示す標識として働くという点です。However を避けたいからといってこれらに置き換えても、同じ問題がそのまま残ります。段落の途中に置いた時点で、読み手はそこを転換点として読みます。置き換えるなら、標識として働かない表現、つまり従属節や but を選びます。